I just typed this post's title and damn if I don't feel borderline geriatric. Girl Talk's pop music pastiche 'mash'terpiece,
Feed The Animals is a decade (and a day) old and honestly, my feelings on it haven't changed an iota. I was enamored with it when it came out, enough so to write two separate pieces about it - one for a Post-Modernism and Popular Culture college class and a much shorter one (below) that
originally appeared on my
Left Off The Dial blog on July 3, 2008 - and still find myself hungering to hear it straight through when the urge hits. Which is often.
We'll revisit my decade-old thoughts in a minute, but can I first say that I love this album as much today as I did when it was first released? It spoke to me like nothing else had since the landmark sample orgy that was the Beastie Boys'
Paul's Boutique. As a teenager armed with only a dual-cassette stereo, I managed to make what I called Mega Mixes, essentially a stylistic precursor to mashups. These minutes-long mixes were a labor of love in that each one involved cuing up a pre-determined song part perfectly on one tape, then hitting Play on that tape deck plus Record on the second tape deck simultaneously to capture the few seconds of the track so it perfectly synced up with the snippet that proceeded it and the one that would follow. That process looks like hell when it's written out and would only net me a few seconds of what would often turn in to a five or seven minute mix. I'd sit in my room, hours on end, completely entranced and engulfed in the process. Lather, rinse, repeat. It was the 80s, I was an only child, and I literally couldn't think of anything I'd rather be doing than that. The final product was often worth it - single artist song collages, remixes of remixes, and in my best moments, creations remotely resembling a rough draft of a Girl Talk composition that wouldn't exist for another 20 years. Man, did I kill a ton of time in the sonic sanctuary of my bedroom back then.
Fast forward to present day and I've listened to
Feed The Animals so many times that it's recontextualized the way I hear the full-length versions of songs contained in it. My expectations for a song that I grew up hearing all the time, like The Guess Who's "These Eyes," no longer serves as a nostalgic trip to my childhood. Girl Talk has delightfully ruined me to the point that I can't hear that song now without instinctively singing the chorus from Mary J. Blige's "Real Love" instead of "These Eyes...cry every night...for you." The same can be said for others. Lil Mama's one-hit wonder, "Lip Gloss" no longer has purpose without the rapid-fire six-stringed assault of Metallica's "One" propping it up. Salt-n-Pepa's 80s anthem "Push It" sounds infinitely better when it's battling against the yeah yeah yeaaaaaaaaah refrain of Nirvana's "Lithium," And I know for a fact that I'll never hear my favorite Of Montreal track, "Gronlandic Edit", without the expectation that Prince's guitar riff from the Purple One's classic "Kiss" will pop up as the tail-end of ...Edit's chorus ("all of the beauty's waaaaaaaaasted") fades out.
Girl Talk took my teenage obsession of curating and crafting Mega Mixes to a whole different planet than I could've possibly imagined. I mean, seriously...I'm still writing about Feed The Animals 10 years later and, with a little luck, I'll still be chirping about it when the album celebrates its 20th anniversary. Until then, here's what I had to say about it shortly after its release.
Girl Talk's Mash-up Mc Nuggets
Juxtaposition. A $10 word that is the crux of Girl Talk's latest (and for that matter every) album, Feed The Animals. Greg Gillis is Girl Talk - a downright polarizing artist - hellbent on taking his brilliant 2006's Night Ripper to the next level. Essentially the musical equivalent of George Dubya- you're either with him or against him - Gillis doesn't allow for middle ground with his art. That's because his “songs” are constructed from all that has come before him.
Gillis serves up a musical stew of others' lyrical snippets, beats, and music to create something familiar, yet wholly unique. Hip-hop and slightly tweaked, yet quickly recognizable guitar parts, are his meat and 'taters. Sticking with my gastronomic analogy, Gillis' unique placement of obscure and ubiquitous samples provide the broth that brings it all into a steaming hot bowl of…well, that depends on interpretation. Detractors say it's derivative and akin to thievery. Supporters praise Gillis for creating postmodern sonic pastiches that stand on their own as original constructions. I lean with the latter, due to Gillis' inventive brilliance.
The concept of a mash-up - taking two songs and blenderizing them - is this decade's version of a cover song. Like most cover songs, a mash-up's noble intent is often not enough to prevent a horrid end product. Gillis takes mash-up's ideology a step further and then proceeds to clone it repeatedly in each "song". What the listener often gets is an alternately awkward and brilliant 25 sample pile-up that is the result of a four-decade excavation of pop, rock, hip-hop, soul and funk. Feed The Animals finds Gillis one step closer to perfecting this formula.
Outkast and UGK get busy over the Spencer Davis Group’s 41-year-old chugging bass line/organ intro of “Gimme Some Lovin’.” Unk’s unstoppable club jam of the last 18 months, “Walk It Out,” and Pete Townshend’s 25-year-old “Let My Love Open The Door” exchange greetings. Rapper T.I. and Sinead O’Connor bounce off each other while a Too Short line about fellatio assumes the roll of chorus. At least for 15 seconds. That’s just the album’s first track, “Play Your Part (pt 1)” - a primer for the 53 minute ADD fest to come.
Gillis has a knack for taking older favorites and slamming them up against the latest hits. The result is a series of memory lane strolls and “WTF?!?” moments that re-contextualize a few generations’ worth of musical nuggets. Avril Lavigne’s smash “Girlfriend” and the well from which it draws (Toni Basil’s “Mickey”) are snipped, clipped, and reshaped into a canvas for Dolla to rap, “Who The Fuck Is That?” over. This is just the first minute of “Shut The Club Down,” which eventually plucks Rod Stewart’s “Young Turks” from the back of pop music’s collective consciousness, re-imagining it as a backing track for Ahmad before Lil’ Jon crashes the party altogether. "WHAT! WHAT?!?"
Gillis has effectively bridged the gap between ubiquitous and obscure. There are tons of these head-scratching and booty-shaking moments on
Feed The Animals, commanding multiple listens to absorb it all.
Girl Talk’s aural collages invite music fans regardless of age or genre loyalty. The truly initiated will discover new within the recognizable and never hear the familiar the same way again. There's a little something in this stew for everyone to love or hate.
Whether you call him a a genius or an easy target for copyright infringement lawyers, Gillis acknowledges every sample in his liner notes to avoid becoming the latter, yet never fully realizes the former. Instead, Gillis and his creations lie in the gray area. A place his audience and critics will not be spending a lot of time in. This particular blogger, however, has leased a timeshare in Gillis' musical scavenger hunt.
And for all y'all music nerds like myself, here's a
cheat sheet of samples on
Feed The Animals.